# Per-resolution vs per-reply AI support pricing

> Compare per-resolution, per-conversation and per-reply AI support pricing with worked examples, sourced vendor prices and a formula you can reuse.

Per-resolution pricing charges only for conversations the AI closes, while per-reply pricing charges for each AI message, so the cheaper model depends on your resolution rate and how many replies a conversation takes. At four replies per conversation and Pommy's Pro rate, per-reply is cheaper than Fin above about a 12% resolution rate.

Published: 2026-11-09 · Last updated: 2026-11-09

**Disclosure:** Pommy wrote this and sells per-reply pricing. All vendor prices were read on the vendors' own pages on 9 November 2026 and can change. Volumes and resolution rates below are assumptions for illustration, not measurements.

## What billing units do AI support vendors use?

- **Per outcome or resolution:** you pay when the AI closes the conversation.
- **Per automated interaction:** similar, with the vendor's own definition of automated.
- **Per conversation:** you pay for each AI-handled conversation, resolved or not.
- **Per reply or message:** you pay for each AI message.
- **Credits:** a pool that drains at a rate the vendor sets.

## Why aren't the units comparable at face value?

A dollar per resolution and three cents per reply describe different things. The first scales with how often the AI succeeds, and the second with how much it talks. A long conversation that ends in a handover costs nothing on per-resolution pricing, and it costs several replies on per-reply pricing. A short conversation that the AI closes in one message is the reverse.

## What is the break-even formula?

Cost per conversation

```
Per-resolution = resolution rate x price per resolution
Per-reply      = average AI replies x price per reply
Break-even resolution rate = (average replies x price per reply) / price per resolution
```

Above the break-even rate, per-reply is cheaper. Below it, per-resolution is cheaper. With four replies per conversation at Pommy's Pro rate ($0.030) and Fin at $0.99, break-even is 0.12 / 0.99, or about 12%. At ten replies per conversation it rises to about 30%.

## What does this look like at three volumes?

Illustrative arithmetic. Assumptions: four AI replies per conversation and a 40% resolution rate. Only the AI charge is compared here, so seats, helpdesk plans and tickets are excluded.

| Conversations a month | Fin at $0.99 per outcome | Gorgias AI Agent at $1.00 | Pommy (plan that fits) |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 400 | $158.40 | $160 | $79 (Growth, 1,600 replies) |
| 2,000 | $792 | $800 | $299 (Pro, 8,000 replies) |
| 6,000 | $2,376 | $2,400 | Scale, priced by conversation (24,000 replies) |

At four replies per conversation, Growth or Pro works out to about $0.12 to $0.13 per conversation at full use. Those plan fees are flat, so below full use the effective cost per reply is higher: Growth at 400 conversations is about $0.20 per conversation.

## Where does per-reply pricing lose?

- **Long conversations.** At 20 replies per conversation and Pro's rate, you pay $0.60 per conversation. Fin at a 40% resolution rate works out to about $0.40.
- **Low resolution rates.** If the AI rarely closes anything, per-resolution bills rarely and per-reply bills anyway.
- **Very low volume on a paid plan.** A flat $79 for a handful of conversations is worse than paying per outcome, though Pommy's Free plan covers 500 replies at no charge.

## What do vendors charge, as of 9 November 2026?

| Vendor | Billing unit | Published price | Source |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Intercom Fin | Outcome | $0.99 per outcome, charged once per conversation. With an existing helpdesk a minimum applies (Intercom gives 50 outcomes as an example). | [intercom.com/pricing](https://www.intercom.com/pricing) |
| Gorgias AI Agent | Automated interaction | $0.90 on annual, $1.00 on monthly. Each also counts as a helpdesk ticket. | [gorgias.com/pricing](https://www.gorgias.com/pricing) |
| Tidio Lyro | Conversation | First 50 conversations free, lifetime. Paid from $32.50 for 50 a month. Plan prices appear to be annual-billing figures; the page does not confirm. | [tidio.com/pricing](https://www.tidio.com/pricing/) |
| Crisp | AI credits | $45 Mini (about 90 AI conversations), $95 Essentials (about 450), $295 Plus (about 1,350) | [crisp.chat/en/pricing](https://crisp.chat/en/pricing/) |
| Chatbase | Message credits | Billed yearly: $32 (700 credits), $120 (4,000), $400 (15,000). The page does not define a credit. | [chatbase.co/pricing](https://www.chatbase.co/pricing) |
| Pommy | AI reply | Free 500, Growth $79 for 2,500 (by conversation), Pro $299 for 10,000, Scale on request | [Pommy pricing](/pricing) |

Gorgias's page carries two conflicting sets of helpdesk plan prices in its structured data, so we quote only the AI Agent rate here. Zendesk's AI rate is omitted because we could not find a first-party figure.

## What costs sit outside the headline price?

- Seats. Intercom prices seats separately ($19 to $132 on its page, with the billing term unstated) on top of Fin.
- Tickets. Gorgias counts each automated interaction as a ticket, so it uses your plan's ticket allowance too.
- Branding. Chatbase charges $99 a month to remove its label.
- Channels. WhatsApp adds [Meta's own per-message fees](/blog/whatsapp-ai-chatbot-cost-2026), whichever vendor you use.

## How do I get my own numbers first?

1. **Count conversations** — Pull last month's total from your helpdesk or inbox, including conversations a person answered.
2. **Sample the length** — Read 50 conversations and count the assistant messages in each. Averages from a vendor's demo are no use for your own traffic.
3. **Estimate the resolution rate** — In the same sample, count how many were settled with no person involved, and be strict about it. A customer who gave up is not resolved.
4. **Run the formula with both numbers** — Do it for your average month and your busiest, because a flat plan and a per-outcome bill diverge most at the peaks.

## Which model fits which kind of support?

| Your support looks like | Usually cheaper | Why |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Short questions settled in one or two messages | Per-reply | You pay for very few messages per conversation |
| Long troubleshooting threads | Per-resolution | Message count climbs, resolution count does not |
| Most conversations end with a person | Per-resolution | Handed-over conversations cost nothing there, and cost every reply on per-reply |
| You need a predictable monthly number | A flat plan with a stated limit | The bill cannot move, as long as you accept what happens at the limit |

## What should you ask a vendor?

- What exactly counts as a resolution, and who decides?
- Does a conversation that ends in a handover count?
- Is there a monthly minimum, and what is it?
- What happens at the limit: extra charges, or the AI stops?
- Are seats, tickets or channels billed separately?

On Pommy, reaching your limit moves conversations to your human queue rather than adding charges, and the [pricing page](/pricing) lists what counts as a reply.

---

Read this page on the web: [Per-resolution vs per-reply AI support pricing](/blog/ai-support-pricing-per-resolution-vs-per-reply)
